Can a Mechanic be Liable for Poor Repairs Causing a Crash?

Mechanics have a responsibility to customers to exercise a reasonable degree of care when performing car repairs. If they neglect this duty and, as a result, contribute to an accident, the mechanic can be held liable for any injuries, property damage, or other losses. A car accident attorney in Charleston, WV may be able to assist you if you were involved in a wreck caused by an improperly repaired vehicle.

How Can a Mechanic’s Negligence Cause an Accident?

Here are some scenarios illustrating how a mechanic’s negligence can cause a car accident:

Wrongful Repairs

If a mechanic fails to correctly identify and address issues during repairs, it can lead to a compromised vehicle performance. For instance, improperly repaired brakes, steering components, or critical engine parts may malfunction, increasing the risk of an accident.

Improper Diagnosis

Incorrectly diagnosing the root cause of a vehicle issue can result in unnecessary repairs or neglecting the actual problem. This may lead to unexpected malfunctions while driving, posing a danger to the driver and others on the road.

Fraudulent Repairs

Some mechanics may engage in fraudulent practices, claiming to have performed repairs that were never done. In such cases, crucial safety components could be left unattended, creating a potential risk of failure and accidents.

Installation of Faulty Parts

If a mechanic installs defective or substandard parts during repairs, it can compromise the overall safety and functionality of the vehicle. These parts may fail unexpectedly, leading to accidents.

Unsafe Repair Practices

Mechanics who do not adhere to proper safety standards or industry guidelines during repairs can introduce risks. For example, improperly securing components, neglecting safety checks, or using incorrect tools may result in accidents.

Incorrect Tire Repairs

Mechanics may improperly repair tires or overlook issues during the repair process. Inadequate tire repairs can result in blowouts or loss of tire integrity, leading to accidents, especially at high speeds.

It’s crucial for mechanics to uphold a duty of care, follow proper diagnostic procedures, use quality parts, and adhere to safety standards during repairs. Negligence in any of these areas can compromise the safety of a vehicle, increasing the risk of accidents and putting lives at stake on the road.

How to Prove a Mechanic is Liable for a Car Accident

Proving a mechanic’s liability for a car accident involves establishing the following key elements of negligence:

  • Duty of Care: The mechanic owed you a duty of care because you took your vehicle to them for repairs. Mechanics have a responsibility to perform repairs with a reasonable standard of care to ensure the vehicle is safe to operate.
  • Breach of Duty: The mechanic breached their duty of care. This could involve proving improper repairs, the use of substandard parts, neglecting safety checks, etc.
  • Causation: The mechanic’s negligence was directly responsible for the collision and would not have occurred otherwise.
  • Damages: You suffered damages as a result of the car accident—for example, property damage, physical injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, and other tangible losses.

Proving that a mechanic is responsible for a car accident can be challenging and complex. An experienced Charleston, West Virginia personal injury attorney can help you ensure they are held accountable.